Friday, 1 March 2013

22nd February 2013: Syd Arthur / Rae - Sebright Arms, Hoxton

I'm on my way to the station for this, my second gig of the year, when my trousers suddenly explode. I'd like to say it's with the knowledge of the sheer awesomeness awaiting me this evening, but it's probably more to do with the week I've just spent in the USA, the land of cheese and frying. And fried cheese.

I spend half the walk trying to hold together the offending broken belt, which is now swinging by my knees, before attempting a surreptitious fix on the rush hour platform and then admitting defeat and dumping the whole thing in the bin outside Cafe Nero with a dramatic flourish.

It's EXACTLY like this. Only without the Hollywood star.
Or the palm tree. Come to think of it, it's nothing like this.

My destination tonight (via Fat Face at Waterloo station, to buy a hideously expensive replacement) is the Sebright Arms in... erm... a really difficult part of London to get to from Waterloo station. We're off to see a band called Syd Arthur who I've been told about by tonight's gig buddy, a fine fellow by the name of Tim who I've mentioned once or twice hereabouts. His entire trip from Hull to tonight's show is being paid for by me in exchange for the enormous header you had to scroll past to find anything to read. I'll leave it up to you to decide who got ripped off in that deal.

Suitably belted up I meet up with Tim and the lovely Karin at Waterloo and we begin our journey into the depths of the unknown. Now, I don't know about you, but I'm a bit suspicious of that orange line that suddenly appeared on the Tube map a few years ago. It turned what was previously "Here be monsters" into "Just about doable if you don't mind changing 3 times" - and it's such a trip that we make to Hoxton this evening.

I was under the impression that Hoxton was Hipster Central, but coming out of the Fube* station there are none to be seen. In fact there's nobody at all to be seen as we head towards where the venue is supposed to be, only a racist electrical shop and eventually a council estate.


(*that's a fake tube station, by the way - it claims to be a tube station and has the proper sign and all but it's quite clearly a railway station, with arches and all that railway jazz.)

It's not as if the pub itself looks any more inviting from the outside- the only clue to its contents being the word "Arms" in its name. I suppose it could be a munitions depot, which would more befit its status as square, flat-roofed box with blacked out windows and military grade shutters. Once inside, we slip past all the hipsters (so that's where they were, drinking real ale and wearing giant headphones round their necks) and downstairs into the actual gig venue- which is, to be honest, a cellar. With the standard Victorian ceiling height. Not recommended for holding a bouncy castle party, but great for concealing a secret Austrian family.

It's rather like the Peel in Kingston, pre "facelift"- dank and dirty, raw and gritty. Oh, and dark, crucially- you can't say it's lacking in atmosphere. It's not long before some guys arrive on the stage- drums, saxophone and a not-electric-electric-double bass- accompanied by a lady with a guitar.

"Hello, " she says. "We're called Rae and we're from Bristol. Apart from me, I'm from all over..."

I don't have much time to ponder the physics of such a phenomenon before she starts singing and it becomes unimportant. Leonie Evans is an immediate focal point for the band, with her sometimes breathy, sometimes playful, sometimes downright dirty vocals layering over what can only be described as jazz.



No, wait, come back! It's not like Jazz FM. Or even like Miles Davis, despite Tim's insistence that it is. But then he uses the word "vinyls", so what does he know? No, it's a kind of alternative, very hip sort of Jazz. Maybe like Amy Winehouse would have ended up if she met Nigel Godrich instead of Mark Ronson. There are even Flamenco tinges, made all the more obvious when Leonie starts scat-singing in Spanish on the only track from their debut album they play this evening, "Leda". It's absolutely mesmerising, as are her cupped-hand megaphone impressions somewhere in the middle.

And let's not pretend this is a solo act either, the band have a phenomenal bass player in the shape of Leon Boydon (and a phenomenal double bass in the shape of, um, a small double bass with a pickup). As well as providing some very impressive playing throughout (and I have Grade 7 Double Bass with Merit, so I know), he sets the funky foundations for closing number "Sublime Motion" and takes metaphorical centre stage for a number called "Leon's Metal Android", something I think we can all enjoy even if we weren't there. There's also a drummer called Dan, but unfortunately he's completely obscured by Leonie from where I'm standing. He sounds great though...

Along the way there are tracks called "Song for Friends" and "Magnum Pie" (working titles abound this evening) and then there's a song about Leonie's mum, the main riff of which she gets us to sing over and over with varying degrees of success. I'm trying out some new earplugs so I make it to the end, completely unaware that most people stopped singing ages ago. The lyrics tell a slightly sad and sentimental tale which Karin suspects is the reason for distracting us with the singalong- perhaps Leonie's not too keen on drawing attention to anything more fragile beneath the cool and sassy exterior.



Meanwhile Lorenzo on saxophone harmonises wonderfully with the vocal lines, making a wonderful case for re-appraising sax as a valid musical contribution in this post-Kenny G era. In summary, Rae are excellent. I will definitely be looking out for the new album, but if it's not called "Leon's Metal Android" I'll want my money back.

In the break I make a quick dash for the bar, but return to find that the hipsters have taken over the joint (and my spot) in their lumberjack shirts, non-ironic pornstar moustaches and skinny jeans with belts which work. I therefore end up with a much worse view of...

Syd Arthur

... Which is a shame, although I do immediately spot singer and guitarist Liam Magill's "Hatfield and the North" T-shirt (apparently home-made) which reminds me of the comparisons to the Canterbury sound which have been generating a buzz around this band for the last year or so. Personally, I don't hear it- there's nothing here which sounds like Caravan, or even Hatfield. They are, however, from Canterbury (as am I), which makes me instantly like them for that reason alone.

Who knew Prog T-shirts, Pyschedelic cardigans and
Windy Miller hats went so well together?

This evening's opener "Ode to the Summer" is the Syd Arthur sound all over- fluid, psych-y guitars jangle over a summery melody while multi-instrumentalist Raven Bush (Kate's nephew) adds some fantastic mandolin. It certainly does what it says on the tin, and evokes summer evenings as much as is possible in a dank hole under a boarded-up garage.

In fact everything tonight follows a similar sort of blueprint- bluesy rock with some slightly folky overtones courtesy of Raven's violin or mandolin playing. Oh, and there's the small matter of choruses that have you humming them for days without remembering quite where they came from.

So, why have they hit the radar of "those who must make everything into Prog"? Well, if all of the above make them sound like a fairly ordinary proposition, there's one small factor we've not taken into account- their crazy penchant for odd and shifting time signatures. Counting along gives me nearly as much of a headache as Gavin Harrison and 05Ric - alternate sections of 5/4 and god knows what in "Edge of the Earth" for one thing.

Syd Arthur - never knowingly under-haired.

It's this that causes Tim to proclaim after the gig that it's like seeing King Crimson in 1972. I assume it's that, anyway, since he's given up beer for lent. And actually Tim is not one to try to shoehorn everything good into the big P bucket, so I'm inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt.

Unfortunately, however much I've enjoyed the album prior to the gig and however much I am enjoying it right now as I type, I reach only one conclusion during the gig. As I stand, listening to the band whilst staring at the back of someone's ironically retro patterned sweater several millimetres in front of my nose, I can't help but feel I'm too old for this shit.

I bet Roger Murtaugh wouldn't put up with these conditions.

Yes, down the front at a tiny club gig was where it was at in the early 2000's, in fact I used to actively participate in pogoing and even the odd spot of light moshing when the occasion demanded it. Unfortunately tonight, after 45 minutes of being forced by other people's shoulders to stand up straight and not breathe too heavily, I'm done in. I look down at Karin who is literally two feet tall, and sense she's feeling the same, so we decide to make a break for the bar at the back from where we can see... oh, even less. And what's more, it's the only thoroughfare to and from the loo, making it the worst possible place to stand anyway.

With a shrug, we head upstairs to the pub where we sit nursing a drink between us and experiencing the rest of the gig by means of vibrations through the floor which suggest we're right above the drum kit. It's actually quite interesting, you still get a sense of the crazy time signatures but the only melody is provided by the cheesy dance tunes playing on the pub jukebox. It goes together surprisingly well, actually.

Anyway, fear not, Syd Arthur seem to be going places based on the sell-out crowd and energetic performance tonight, so I suspect I'll have another chance to see them this year, hopefully in a venue where personal space is an option and I don't wake up with a dislocated spine in the morning.

Oh, now I see where the Prog connection came from...

Once the gig is over and everyone starts coming back upstairs, I head down to find Tim, who's rooted to the spot with an odd mixture of confusion and afterglow on his face. "I'm just going to say hello to a few people," he says, and I agree to see him upstairs in a few minutes. When I come back down half an hour later, he's deep in chat with Leonie from Rae and Raven from Syd Arthur. I'm not entirely sure whether he decides to tell Leonie about his theory that she was separated at birth from Victoria Coren but he does tell me afterwards what a tit he feels for telling her she sounds like Kate Bush when Kate's nephew is standing right there. Still, it could be worse, he could have told her all about his "vinyls".

The trip home is pretty much the same as the trip there, only backwards. Although my old belt doesn't fix itself, more's the pity.

Oooh, look it's the Shard. Or is it the Gherkin? Or the Spaniel?

As we get off the train, we come across a drunk man on the footbridge with his foot stuck in a Waitrose carrier bag, hopping around and desperately trying to kick it off. I'd like to think it's a metaphor for my struggle this evening to shake off the shackles of encroaching middle age.

But it isn't. It's just funny.

Tuesday, 22 January 2013

2012: The Year in Albums (Part Two)

Oh, I've really done a number on myself now, haven't I? Even worse than that time I started a new blog about travel, wrote a cracking first post, promised tales of mystery and intrigue in India for the next installment, and then... yeah.

Anyway, I do believe last week I promised a Part Two of my 2012 album round-up, in which I'd rate and review all my favourite prog albums of the year. The problem with this is...

- There are only a limited number of people who would be caught dead listening to a prog album.
- There are only a limited number of prog albums released every year
- There are only a limited number of prog albums released every year which aren't totally wretched.
- Most of the people who would be caught dead listening to prog buy all the prog albums which aren't totally wretched.
- You could probably write my top 10 list yourself based on all of the above.

So I'm not convinced I've got anything new or different to say. Like most prog bands - HA!



Ahem. Anyway, here's my list of prog albums with a few words about each, where useful. And if you scroll down past all the pictures of wizards, you will find some other albums I enjoyed this year (live albums, old albums, boybands...). And some I didn't.


9. Ian Anderson - Thick as a Brick 2


Confession #1: I'd never heard TAAB before I bought this album, I just picked it up because it has a Steven Wilson 5.1 mix on the DVD.

Confession #2: Now I've heard TAAB, I actually think I like this belated sequel better. It's a bit more accessible to the newbie, and I appreciate that that's on a par with saying you prefer 'Tubular Bells II' to the original, but so be it. Plus this one's got a "well clever" cover - you see, these days newspapers are online - get it?

Confession #3 - Although I'm impressed by the fact that 'Shunt and Shuffle' uses the phrase 'Fray Bentos Pies' in its chorus, I can't help but wish Ian hadn't ripped off the main riff from the theme song to  'Super Duper Sumos'.

Key Track: Banker Bets, Banker Wins


8. Stick Men - Deep



Oooh, I don't know if this should be here, since mere mortals aren't going to get to hear this album until later in 2013. I'm just special, you see, and got a pre-release set of MP3's for being part of the Kickstarter campaign to get this album made. Kneel before my Prog philanthropy.

Anyway, I saw Stick Men live earlier this year and explained then why they are pretty much the continuation of the 2000's era King Crimson, since old Bobby is too busy suing people, retiring from music, making an album with Theo Travis and not being invited to play on the new Bowie album.

This album is easily the best they've made so far, and is an absolute must for any Crimson fan, featuring as it does Tony Levin's driving and funky bass stick, as well as his growly vocals on 'Crack in the Sky'. Pat Mastelotto pounds the drums and anything else he can get his hands on, and Markus Reuter makes all kinds of noises with his touch guitar and plenty else besides. There are even more electronic moments than previously- utter bliss for the hipster secret Prog fan.

Key Track: Nude Ascending Staircase (this time I will make no apologies for picking track 1 because it contains everything I love about this album.)



7. Marillion - Sounds That Can't Be Made



Post-Marbles Marillion albums get a bit of a rough-ride in my house - Marbles was the first new album they released after I properly got into them, and coincidentally also managed to be the finest album they'd ever made (certainly in the 'H era'.) Hence everything else was going to have quite something to live up to in my eyes - and sure enough, 'Somewhere Else' really didn't do it for me, and although apparently I have played 'Happiness is the Road' 10 times right through, according to iTunes, I could not hum you a single note from it right now. Well, I could, here's "G" for you. (I'm assuming they used G somewhere.)

Happily, 'Hounds that Can't be Spayed', as I like to call it, is the best album they've made since 'Marbles', although in consistency it's still some distance short of that masterwork. Hence Track 1, 'Gaza', is by far one of the best things they've created in 10 years, despite, or perhaps because of the controversial subject matter, and 'Power' has a hook to die for. Even the title track makes up for a rather plodding start by building to a suitably grandiose ending with a nice Rothery guitar solo, and Mark Kelly adds some mellotron flute-y goodness to 'Pour My Love'.

However, then there's 'Montreal', which whilst being a nice love letter to the city and its people and all, seems to be someone's blog account of their holiday set to music. 

"
So I Skyped home and said "It's me. How are you babe? 
I can't be with you but I can see you on the screen..."

"Going down to breakfast ..What time is it now there? 
I'll go shopping for shoes ..or whatever ensues..."

"Got to my room and found there's no tea
I said to the band, you just can't get a decent cuppa here..."

I made one of those up, but I bet if you haven't heard the song you can't tell which.

Key Track: Gaza



6. Anathema- Weather Systems



You know, I'd ignored Anathema for ages, for some reason. I checked out some old stuff when they supported Porcupine Tree in '07, and wasn't all that fussed. Probably my default Home Counties mistrust of anything Scouse. (Beatles excepted, naturally.) Or maybe it was the fact that they were basically a different band with the same name- a sort of depressing metal band without the metal sounds.

But since people have been going on about them for the last couple of years, I thought I'd give them another try - and I'm rather glad I did.

Are Anathema Prog Rock? Well, no, not really. I'm not even sure they shouldn't have been in Part 1 of this list. Not for them the keyboard solo or the cape, theirs is a more wistful, melancholic take on intelligent music, with gradually building layers of indie guitars, stumbling drum patterns, wonderful male/female vocal harmonies, and spine chilling melodies like "Untouchable", pts 1&2.

And in case we were already missing Pure Reason Revolution (which I certainly am), they even thoughtfully wrote a PRR song for us and included it in the shape of part 1 of "The Storm Before the Calm".

Key Tracks: Untouchable, part 2 / The Storm Before The Calm


5. Kompendium- Beneath the Waves



There was a competition going around on Facebook before this album, the brainchild of Magenta main man Rob Reed, was released- encouraging you to send in a picture of yourself having your first listen. This was part of the whole pre-release campaign which aimed to take you back to the time where we sat down and listened to albums in full whilst poring over gatefold sleeves. I don't know what you could win, a pipe and slippers to wear whilst enjoying the album, presumably.

Anyway, it's a good job I didn't send in a photo of myself having my first listen to this album because (quite apart from the fact that I always look like the Thumb Man when taking my own photo), my face was probably all over the place. "Narration, ok, that's quite prog...Hmmm, now this sounds like Enya, Oh, yep, that could be a Magenta song... EWWWW, Irish Pipes... Oh, that sounds like something from ChimpanA... OPERA SINGING! OH SWEET JESUS..."

Still, once you get past some of the sounds you might not normally listen to, there's a really good album here - sort of like a cross between Mike Oldfield, Riverdance and Phantom of the Opera. Which is not necessarily a bad thing by any means. Prog legends such as Steve Hackett, John Mitchell, Gavin Harrison, Jakko Jakszyk and Chris Fry add to the flavour of Rob Reed's slightly more Celtic-theatrical take on his usual retro-prog Magenta recipe, and ChimpanA's Steve Balsamo is soulful as ever on vocals. Nice.

I should also say that, although I took the piss earlier out of the whole "wasn't everything better in the 70's" thing - this whole package oozes class, from the oversized gatefold CD packaging with lyrics inside, to the DVD disc containing the whole album in genuinely audiophile Advanced Resolution 5.1 Surround sound, which is as surefire a way as I know of checking that your system sounds good.

Key Tracks:  The Storm (one for Magenta fans)  /  Beneath the Waves (one for ChimpanA fans - you may wish to steer clear of the cheesy video, though...) / Lilly (one for fans of Steve Hackett playing acoustic guitar whilst wistful female vocals mourn lost love before turning into a Mike Oldfield track)


4. Rush - Clockwork Angels


Oh dear, I've done it now - I'm expecting a strongly worded text message any day now for not putting this at number 1. Truth be told, it's only in the last 18 months that I've become a fan of Rush at all, after seeing them live in 2011, and finally starting to 'get it' and stop paying attention to the fact that Geddy Lee frequently yelps like a dog when you step on its tail.

Anyway, this being the first new Rush album since I 'discovered' them, I was pretty excited, and it's fair to say I wasn't disappointed at all - in fact I've now played it more than any other Rush album and it's therefore my favourite Rush album other than 'Moving Pictures'. (Here comes another text...)

What does it sound like? Well, it sounds like Rush, obviously. Duhhh. And most importantly, there's not a duff track on it - which I certainly can't say for any other Rush album in the last 20 years. (Oh, is that my phone again?)

Key Tracks: Caravan / The Wreckers


3. Flying Colors - Flying Colors


Oh, Hi, Neal Morse. What's that -  you've joined a supergroup, and you're making an album? Gee, that is a shocker. It's got Mike Portnoy on drums? You don't say... It's an album full of prog epics, designed to take us back to the old days of the 70's when everything was wonderful, with lyrics composed entirely of thinly veiled religious claptrap?

What? It isn't? Oh alright then, maybe I'll check it out...

I think if you'd told me back in January that my number 3 album of the year would be a Neal Morse supergroup project, I would have looked at you like a cat trying to comprehend Lego. Don't get me wrong, I've really liked pretty much everything that Neal's been involved in over the years and especially Transatlantic, but I couldn't help but feel last year that it was time to change the record a little.

And apparently so did he - right from the off, this album sets its stall out pretty clearly. Firstly- it's not really a prog album, or if it is it's more of a prog-pop album like It Bites or Kino. Secondly, Neal doesn't actually sing all that much and certainly not about Jesus. Neal is basically the band's keyboard player (something which is even more apparent when you see them live, which I heartily recommend) and does backing vocals and the odd spot of lead alongside new boy Casey McPherson and legends Dave LaRue from Dixie Dregs and his bandmate Steve Morse (also in Deep Purple since 1994.)

Along the way, they have a couple of songs which sound a bit like Muse in that metal-baroque-riffery kind of way (see 'Shoulda Woulda Coulda'), and some pretty nice power ballads like 'Everything Changes'. And then, finally, at the end, there's a 12-minute epic ('Infinite Fire') which is by far the Morse (N)-iest thing on the album. And do you know what, for being alongside so much other good, straightforward rock music, it's all the more effective when it finally comes.

Key Tracks: Blue Ocean / Shoulda Woulda Coulda / Infinite Fire


2. It Bites - Map of the Past



It's another concept album - huzzah! What's that? What's it about? No idea. We established last week that I'm rubbish at this kind of thing. There's something about a man in a wartime photograph, although to be fair that's nothing you can't tell from the cover. Then there's a wallflower and some clocks, and a meadow and a stream... and then some cartoons, and a boy who draws his Daddy and cruelly scribbles out his eyes (ouch.) Actually, are we sure it's a concept album? I might be making it up, like the time I was convinced there was a story in 'The Incident' by Porcupine Tree and spent hours working it out, only for me to explain it to Karin and have her look at me as if she thought I might need taking into care.

Anyway, none of that is important right now. Or indeed, at all. This album is absolutely cracking - quite possibly the best It Bites have ever served up. No longer do they sound like they're trying to justify the use of the band name (no dumbree-umbree-yay-yo this time around), instead Messrs Mitchell and Beck have concentrated on giving us some of the best tunes they've ever concocted, from the rocking 'Wallflower' and the bouncy title track, to the genuinely haunting 'The Last Escape'. And in the middle, there's a bona fide radio hit in the shape of 'Cartoon Graveyard', and the mostly overtly proggy thing they've done for years, in 7/8 and everything ('Meadow and the Stream').

Key Tracks: The Big Machine / Meadow and the Stream / The Last Escape



Any other year, this would have been a shoo-in for number one... except...

1. Big Big Train- English Electric, Part 1



Okay, hands up who saw that one coming. Yeah, all of you. There's one album this year which has got everyone excited about being a Prog fan again, and it's this one.

*BORING STORY ALERT* I first heard Big Big Train back in the early 2000's, when I was something of a bigshot in the Genesis bootleg trading community, and naturally thus fending off the ladies left, right and centre.

I traded a couple of times with a chap called Greg, who eventually ran out of things I wanted and offered to send me a couple of albums from his band instead. Those albums were, I think, Bard and English Boy Wonders- and I listened to and liked them at the time but didn't really get heavily into them. I was therefore watching proudly from the sidelines as my boy Spawton went from strength to strength and started gaining critical acclaim from the Prog elite for albums such as 'The Difference Machine' and 'The Underfall Yard', at which point I jumped back on the bandwagon to discover that he'd absolutely nailed it.

Yes, in recent years, BBT has found both a stable line-up including, critically, ex-XTC man Dave Gregory, should-have-been Genesis vocalist David Longdon and drumming legend Nick D'Virgilio - together with a marvellous sound which is all their own, despite the obvious nods to days gone by. My friend Tim completely hit the nail on the head with his summation here, where he correctly worked out that BBT had managed to capture the spirit of early Genesis (or 'visit the giftshop' as he so eloquently put it), without actually sounding like Genesis.

Indeed, if there's anything more English than this album (other than 'Selling England by the Pound'), I'll eat my bowler hat. From the cover art suggesting decaying industry, to stories of English heroes, rogues and engineers and travels through West Country landscapes, English Electric takes us on a proper journey around our fair land and its characters. It also skilfully manages to avoid using every prog cliche in the book - something helped in large part by the influence from Dave Gregory's other projects and Nick D'Virgilio's innovative drumming which puts one in mind of Phil Collins only in innovative approach rather than sound.

And what's my most-played song of all in 2012? Was it a massive prog behemoth, or some kind of pounding electro dancefloor smash? No, it's a whimsical little banjo-driven tale of hedgerows, honeysuckles and yellowhammers called 'Uncle Jack', in which the band manage to encapsulate everything that's so wonderful about our green and pleasant land without making you want to join UKIP.

Key Tracks: Uncle Jack / Summoned By Bells / Hedgerow



Oh hang on, what's this...?


Echolyn - Echolyn



I know a few people will have been shaking their heads when I appeared to have missed this out, saying "whaaaaa?" or something more erudite - but the truth is this just came to my attention too late in the year for me to get to know it properly. And I'd hate to pass proper judgement on a couple of plays, but I can tell already that there are going to be many more in 2013. And the cover looks a bit like 'Misunderstanding'.



Live Albums of the Year

Say, what? People are still making live albums? Well, yes, it appears that they are... or one man is, at least - with no fewer than 4 live albums from the Steven Wilson stable of artists. 'Catalog / Preserve / Amass' served as a little taster for the main course which was...

Steven Wilson - Get All You Deserve



...which wins Live Album of the Year purely by virtue of being the only one which was a full concert which you didn't have to buy a reissue of something you already owned to get hold of. And the Blu-ray portion of the release, showing off the cool visuals I saw live back in November last year didn't hurt, either.

Other notable SW-related live albums came from No-Man, whose superlative 'Love and Endings' album was taken from another concert I attended (get me), and Porcupine Tree, whose 'Octane Twisted' live album was nice but not earth-shattering.

If your name was not Steven Wilson, it seemed that it was ok to release live shows as long as you packaged them up with a reissued studio album. Peter Gabriel served us up an excellent live concert from Athens in 1987 along with the crazy box set version of 'So', and Mike Oldfield finally opened up the vaults to bring us two wonderful vintage shows from the 70's and 80's on his reissues of 'Platinum' and 'QE2'.




New-Old albums of the Year

Here's part 2 of my 6-word review series of old albums I discovered in 2012 (snappy title, I know.)

Kate Bush - Live at Hammersmith Odeon (1981/1994)

Bonkers chanteuse's only live tour. Wowooowowoowow...


Richard Wright - Broken China (1996)

The best album Floyd never made.


Kevin Gilbert - The Shaming of the True (2000)

Tortured genius' bitter concept masterpiece. Shame.


Tears For Fears - Raoul & The Kings of Spain (1994)

80s Popsters turn serious, exit charts.


Talk Talk - The Colour of Spring (1986)

Band confuses public. Gains permanent fanbase.


Tin Spirits - Wired to Earth (2011)

Dave Gregory's other band. More chipper.



Anyway, clearly I can't have enjoyed everything that came my way this year, can I? I do have some critical faculties. Here I present for you...

The Gigging Forever "Nahhhh" awards 2012

Most pointless album, 2012:

Steve Hackett - Genesis Revisited II


Beautiful cover, isn't it?

My relationship with this album went a little along these lines:

Play 1: Ahhh, cracking song. Ooh, haven't heard that one for ages. Oh, he changed that guitar solo a bit, that's interesting. And the different vocalists are a cool idea. It's like everything sounds fresh and new - but with all the same sounds I already love - brilliant!

Plays 2-3: Hmm, ok, some of these vocals are a bit ropey. Why is that man shouting 'Blood on the Rooftops'? And who let Nad Sylvan anywhere near the studio, and why didn't they give him the lyrics to read instead of letting him make up his own?

Plays 4-5: Yeah, that guitar solo's not as good as the original. Skip. Skip again. 'The Lamia' is pretty nice. And so's 'Entangled'. Where are my Genesis CDs? Ahh, that's better.

Plays 6+: N/A


'Much Ado About Nothing' Award, 2012:

Storm Corrosion - Storm Corrosion


Well, if ever an album was musical Marmite, I guess this is it. It's not that I expected it to sound like Opeth or Porcupine Tree, I just expected it to sound like something. This is just a whole load of 'blah'. I don't think I've ever made it to the end without giving up.

Still, 'Drag Ropes', with the video, was actually pretty cool. Perhaps there's a really strong EP here, struggling to get out.

Sunday, 13 January 2013

2012: The Year In Albums (Part One)

About a year ago, I had this really cool idea. What if I wrote about all the albums I'd bought over the previous 12 months with the intent of informing people about music they might have missed - perhaps I could even place them into some kind of order, like a run down of increasing quality. Then I'd say a few words about each one and make some sarcastic jokes, you know, my usual kind of thing. I'd make it mostly albums that I really, genuinely loved, and then I'd chuck in a couple near the beginning of the list which I didn't necessarily get, but which made me sound much cooler than I really was (am? Tying myself up in tenses here.)

It turned out to be so popular, I was actually thinking of doing the same thing every January. So imagine my surprise and extreme disappointment to find that this year, not only has every other bastard with a laptop decided to rip off my idea, but they've even tried to steal a march on me by doing it before 2012 was even finished. Not cool, people. Not cool at all.



Ahhhhh, I'll be honest with you. Last year I was really scratching around to find 10 new albums that I wanted to nail my colours to. How else can I explain the appearance of Yes on the list? This year, by contrast, has been one of the best for new music in living memory. So much so that my initial shortlist for albums of the year was 34 albums - that's the same number of new releases as I bought in the entire of 2011.

This year I bought an impressive 66 new release albums, and rating them is a fairly impossible task, ranging as they do from shoegazey, reverb-drenched electronica to Celtic prog, and everything in between. I can't even fall back on last year's "stats" approach thanks to a catastrophic hard-drive crash early in the year losing 3 months of playcounts in my iTunes library. Yep, these are the things which keep me awake at night.

So, in the interests of fairness, I've divided the shortlist up into 'Prog' and 'Non-Prog'. And because I know that most of the people reading this will be prog fans, I'm going to deliberately make you wait until Part 2 for the prog albums otherwise you won't bother reading the rest of it, will you? I know what you hobbit-botherers are like.

Here we go, then. It's Gigging Forever's countdown of "every album I bought this year, shoehorned into some lame category to prevent me having to make too many decisions"...

11. (Who says I can't have 11? Do you want to take it outside?) Porcelain Raft - Strange Weekend


I've just realised that this looks a bit like... 
well, I'll let you use your imagination.

If you read my review of M83 live in Brighton back in January (which, let's face it, hardly anyone did), you'll have heard all about the spacey, echoey, dreamy sounds of Porcelain Raft, and how they caused me to nearly cack my pants. The CD is a slightly less disturbing event, and got heavy rotation during stressful periods of work this year, being the kind of aural equivalent of a hot bath with lots of bubbles.

Key Track - Oooh, let's say 'Drifting In And Out' (of the suds) -  choosing track 1 of every album again...


10. Marina & The Diamonds - Electra Heart



Right at the beginning of the year, I picked up 'The Family Jewels', Marina Diamandis' first album as Marina and the Diamonds, for the princely sum of £1.99, and it turned out to be a cracking investment, featuring very cleverly written, quirky pop songs which put me in mind of a young Kate Bush.

Now, you may come to learn this about me over time but I'm not very good at paying attention to, remembering or understanding lyrics, which therefore renders me not quite clever enough to get just how ironic this second album supposedly is - but apparently it's a satire on young pop starlets, their superficial lives and their vacuous pop outpourings. Well, I don't know about that, but it sounds like a great, fun, slightly vicious album of intelligent, dance-y pop music, which is all fine and dandy in my book.

Key Track - 'Radioactive' (No, ok, it's not on the standard edition of the album but it's a fantastic song.)


9. Keane - Strangeland



I'm not quite sure why I've decided to put this on the list. I actually really liked 'Perfect Symmetry' (their previous album, which saw them doing away with all their cliches in favour of a gaudy, brash, 80's influenced layer on top of some excellent songs, aided by super-producer Stuart Price) - and this album feels a lot like "Sorry, we went a bit too far, please come back and play us on Radio 2 again".


But there's a warm familiarity which creeps over as soon as you hear that CP-70 electric piano sound on opener 'You Are Young', there are soaring, singalong choruses, and the front cover looks like the seaside and therefore reminds me of my childhood. And it's my blog and I can do what I like.

Key track - 'Neon River' is pretty anthemic, whilst steering just on the right side of mawkish.


8. Beach House - Bloom



You know that Porcelain Raft album I chose above? Yeah, this is nearly the same album -  dreamy, spacey, wistful sounds which make you nostalgic for people and places you may or may not have ever known. Someone should probably sue someone. This album rates slightly higher on my list because:


a) Beach House have male and female vocals (Porcelain Raft are basically a one man band)
b) Their tunes are 14% more catchy
c) Cool people like this album and have put it on their end of year lists too
d) Their album cover doesn't look like lady parts - but it does make your eyes go funny if you stare at it too long
e) They haven't made me crap my pants (yet.)

Key Track - 'Wild' (ignore the video which seems to be a fly-on-the-wall documentary about heroin addiction.)


7. Field Music - Plumb / Play





Hold on a minute, that's two albums! Well, yes, it is, but 'Play' is a short album of cover versions - the kind of thing which unscrupulous record labels try to sell you as a bonus disc when you buy the same album for the second time - so it counts as part of 'Plumb'. Honest. Also the covers are nearly the same (and look suspiciously like the station I can see from my living room window.)

Anyway, 'Plumb' made it to Prog magazine's best of 2012 list, which could make it a candidate for my 'other' list, but to be honest I think sometimes people are so desperate to only like music in one genre that they try to drag anything else they like into it so they don't lose cred.

I can almost see their point, with it being an incredibly inventive guitar-based rock album, where completely unrelated and stylistically quite different songs flow into each other in a way which seems totally natural. (It might even prove to be a concept album if I pay attention to the lyrics.) And I guess opening track 'Start the Day Right' has grinding 'I am the Walrus' strings, bringing to mind very early ELO, and there are complex rhythms and shifting moods, all in 2 minutes and 18 seconds. Ah, yes, here's why it's not prog. None of the songs are longer than 3 and a half minutes, in fact they get through 5 songs in the first 12 minutes. Most prog bands can't keep a keyboard solo as short as that.

'Play' is a more traditional affair, with 8 inventive cover versions ranging from Syd Barrett to the Pet Shop Boys - and deserves to be on this list solely for the remarkable feat of making Ringo's 'Don't Pass Me By' from the White Album sound like an actual song instead of something a toddler made up on the spot.

Key Tracks: 'A New Town' (Plumb) / 'Rent' (Play)


6. Pet Shop Boys - Elysium



Oh, look at that. My pick from the last album above was a Pet Shop Boys cover, and now here's the real thing.


Have the Pet Shop Boys ever made a bad album? Assuming you think they ever made a good one, I think you'd have to agree that they've had a pretty good run of things, especially of late, with 2009's 'Yes' being a revival of the more outgoing side of PSB. Here they're back in the introspective and subdued mode that served them well on 'Behaviour' and 'Bilingual', with 'Invisible' and 'Breathing Space' being some of the most personal and touching songs they've ever recorded.

There's still plenty of room for fun, though, as the Diva-bashing 'Ego Music' and the typically self-referential 'Your Early Stuff' prove - the lyrics of the latter being composed entirely of cretinous things said to Neil Tennant by taxi drivers. "You've been around, but you don't look too rough / And I still quite like some of your early stuff..." And I think we can forgive the rather OTT Olympic Anthem 'Winner' in the context of this summer's excitement.

Key Track: Leaving (look, I can't help it if bands keep putting their best tracks first on their albums, can I?)


5. iamamiwhoami - Kin



Sometimes I'm glad I'm not right on the pulse of what's hip and cool, otherwise I think I'd get frightfully annoyed with some of the absolute bullshit that happens in the name of 'art' (or is it 'promotion'?) - this album being a case in point, with all kinds of teasers and trailers and odd videos and massive, massive hype being posted online for a year or so in the lead-up to this album.

No, I'm very happy just to get a text from my friend Mark saying 'I've been listening to this song on repeat for hours', click onto Youtube and hear 'Goods', and thence directly to Amazon to hear what else Jonna Lee and Claes Björklund have to offer.

And what do they have to offer? Well, if Beach House and Porcelain Raft are a comfy soak in a hot tub, iamamiwhoami is more like lying shivering and naked in the foetal position on the floor of a room in a Scandinavian ice hotel while Lykke Li sings in the corridor outside.

Glacial, minor chords, chiming synths and off-kilter beats assault the senses whilst Jonna moans and shrieks by turns. Oh, and some catchy tunes too, the gits. The videos are downright bonkers, though -you have been warned.

Key Track: Drops (no, I don't know what the hairy creatures are all about, either)


4. Lindstrøm - Six Cups of Rebel / Smalhans





Oh, I'm cheating again... Yeah, ok, again this is two albums. Although the second one clocks in at less than 30 minutes - but to tell the truth I couldn't separate these. Following last year's obsession with Hans-Peter and his epic 'Space Disco' masterpiece 'Where You Go, I Go Too', both these albums were always going to be an instant buy.

'Six Cups of Rebel' is Lindstrøm's more indulgent side, where he seems to have gone all out with whatever he felt like doing, whether it was a good idea or not. Hence 'No Release' is basically 5 minutes of cycling church organ, and 'Call Me Anytime' breaks down in the middle into what sounds like a small child bashing on a Casio keyboard. But then there's the funky-as-anything 'De Javu' with stabbing brass and disco beats, the drum-solo freakout of the title track, and the fantastic closing 'Hina', which is easily the closest we come to the cosmic dancefloor of 'Where You Go', albeit with a quirky edge befitting its place on this quite unusual album.

On 'Smalhans' (upon which every track is named after some kind of Norwegian traditional dish for some reason), he's back to what he does best: 6 more straightforward tracks for the dancefloor (also ace for running). But his twisted, minor-chord, Scandinavian take on things takes you on a crazy journey far deeper than any of his more popular contemporaries. Probably a journey in the snow. With elks.

I'll leave the last word to electro-pop princess Little Boots, on twitter, as I can't think of any higher praise than this, about closing track Vā-Flę-R (Waffles):

"The last track on the new @Lindstrom album is like the greatest Mario level ever. Definitely involving Yoshi."

Key Tracks: De Javu (Six Cups of Rebel) / Vā-Flę-R (Smalhans)


3. Ben Folds Five - The Sound of the Life of the Mind




I think I made my feelings on Ben Folds Five fairly clear a few weeks ago after their London gig, during which they played 8 of this album's 12 songs- all of which were greeted like old favourites, and with good reason. I'm therefore not going to waste my time (or yours, for that matter) writing tons about this.

With their trademark rollicking piano, thundering rock 'n roll drum fills, rock solid bass, and clever-clever lyrics ("I was puzzled, when it was feet on gravel / To have come apart, I must once have been ravelled..."), this album delivered exactly what was expected, and somehow without sounding like a tired retread.

Key Track: Hold That Thought is one of the less obvious tracks from the album, but really does it for me, for some reason. Not in that way. Or, Erase Me is a more standard BFF song - nice and angry. Let the hate flow through you, young Ben...


2. Muse - The Second Law




You know, if you want to be Queen, there comes a point where you have to make 'Hot Space'. And I don't mean what you think I mean by that. No, I do know what you think I mean. You think I mean you have to make a rubbish disco album, don't you? Told you.

No, what I mean is that you have to:

- Wonder how far you can go down the same old well-trodden path before people get bored
- Record some songs which are exactly what you want to record, perhaps including influences from some modern acts you enjoy yourselves
- Put them on your album along with some other songs which are still in your classic sound
- Sit back and let people get all het up about how rubbish your new album is, and how you're trying too hard to be cool, based solely on a few 3 tracks with some more modern sounds in them.
- Watch the entire of the internet slate your album (Currently rated at 2.4 out of 5 on Rate Your Music)

So what did they actually do here? Opener 'Supremacy' is exactly what it would sound like if Muse wrote a James Bond theme, and is perfectly in their grand album opener tradition. 'Survival' is gloriously OTT Queen-inspired pomposity, perfect for its status as official Olympic anthem, 'Animals' is your typical "angry, sneering Muse" song, and 'Explorers' is as wonderful a ballad as they've ever recorded, in the tradition that goes all the way back to 'Unintended' from their debut.

What does that leave us with? Well, it leaves us with two sets of songs which seem to have divided people - Firstly the 'Muse-step' songs, a "hilarious" misnomer for what are essentially Muse songs with a few modern production sounds added to them: 'Madness' with its 'wub wub wub' bassline, and 'Follow Me' which builds up from gentle pulsating synths to a wonderful climax with some of Matt's best vocals underpinned by what I assume are dub-step style whooshing / pounding noises (yeah, I'm so down with teh dubstep...) And then there's 'Panic Stations', which seems to be the one that's got most people annoyed but is essentially 'Another One Bites the Dust' for the 2010's, with some wonderfully funky brass-synth stabs and rhythm guitar. Ok, so the two-part closer 'The Second Law' is pretty out there in its symphonic-electro stylings and apocalyptic hysteria but since when we were holding it against Muse for being mental?

The second group of songs causing them problems are the two songs near the end of the album written by bassist Chris Wolstenholme. We all know what happens when you let the bass player/drummer write a couple of songs, don't we? Well no, actually, we don't (just look at our old favourite reference point Queen for a fantastic example of why it's good to diversify.) 'Save Me' is perhaps the most surprising song on the whole album, far more than any of those I mentioned above, in that it sounds nothing like Muse at all - helped partially by the fact that it's Chris singing it, but also in that it sounds much more like something belonging on an Anathema album, with its gently pounding drums, jangly guitars and understated vocal harmonies. In many ways it's the best thing here, although it's starkly at odds with the rest of the album. Perhaps it's time for Chris to make a solo album, I'd buy it.

Key Tracks - 'Madness' / 'Save Me'


1. Saint Etienne - Words and Music By Saint Etienne




"When I was ten, I wanted to explore the world.
There were these older kids at school who'd gone all the way to Somerset,
just to see Peter Gabriel's house.
Peter Gabriel from Genesis.
The way they dressed, the way their hair fell over their coat collars,
It all happened because of music - I wanted to know why.
I couldn't go to Somerset on my own,
So I used Top of the Pops as my world atlas..."

If there's one album this year whose lyrics and concept I did very much pay attention to, it's this one. It's almost as if they knew exactly how to get my interest within 10 seconds- the breathily intoned spoken word intro from Sarah Cracknell using words like "Peter Gabriel" which are always guaranteed to awake me from dozing, or pretending to work, or whatever I'm doing.

The entire album is a love letter to pop music itself- from the extremely clever cover with its faux A-Z map of London using street names and locations from the band's favourite pop songs, to the themes of the lyrics.

Opener 'Over the Border' recalls the teenage thrill of discovering and being obsessed by new bands, artists, record labels, and growing up wondering whether all this would still seem so important when school was done with (spoiler: yes). 'I've Got Your Music' is all about the delights of having your favourite song on headphones as the world passes by all around you, and 'DJ' is, well, you know. And then there's 'Tonight', which recalls the thrill of getting ready to go and see a favourite band, wondering what they're going to play, cramming on the new album before you leave- an experience eerily recreated by me when seeing Saint Etienne themselves at the Palladium earlier this year.

In fact, the album could only have been more self-referential if they'd included a song called 'You know when you buy an album and you really like it and then you realise there's a special edition with bonus tracks so you buy that too, and then you realise there was a very limited deluxe boxset which is going for £100 on eBay which has 3 extra songs on it and a poster of the artwork and then you find a Spanish website selling that for £30, so you order it and sell the other editions but it takes ages to arrive and in fact you don't even think it will, so you buy the special edition again and order an even bigger version of the poster from somewhere else, and then the ruddy box turns up in the post - and THEN they release a new version only in the US, with ten entirely new songs on the second disc'.

One for the remastered edition, perhaps.

Oh, what does the music sound like? Well, it's like most Saint Etienne: shimmery, summery, slightly melancholy dance-indie-pop, that somehow manages to sound rooted in the 60s despite a thoroughly modern sound. I've definitely got their music.

Key Tracks: 'Over The Border' / 'I've Got Your Music' (wonderful video with fans showing off their favourite albums) / Haunted Jukebox


Oh yeah, she's still cute, too.
Picture: MusicOMH.com


You still there? Ah, good. I'm nearly done, but firstly here are 10 of my favourite 'new-old' albums of the year with a six-word review of each (this should be interesting.)


Bombay Bicycle Club - A Different Kind of Fix (2011)


Indie pop band support Blur. Impress.


The Postal Service - Give Up (2003)


Should sue Owl City. Top tunes.



Dragonette - Galore (2007)

Electro pop wonder. Hot vocalist. Yeah!


Depeche Mode - 101 (1989)


Everything you need know about Depeche.


Moloko - Statues (2003)


Quirky prog dance. Awesome in surround.


Pugwash - The Olympus Sound (2011)


Beatles and ELO go Irish. Sublime.


Phoenix - Live! Thirty Days Ago (2004)


French indie band better on stage.


Orbital - Middle of Nowhere (1999)


Wish I'd heard this in field.


Robyn - Body Talk (2010)


Kickarse Swedish popstress goes gangsta. Fierce.


M83 - Before the Dawn Heals Us (2005)


New favourite band. Best old album.


Everything Everything - Man Alive (2010)


Jerky indie rock. Inventive stuff. Txtspk.


Holy Ghost - Holy Ghost! (2011)


American indie dance channels Cut Copy.


Wait, you're STILL there? Okay, here's a little easter egg for you...

The Gigging Forever "Silly Artwork" award 2012 goes to:

The Sabres of Paradise - Sabresonic II (2001)



Anyone like to have a guess as to what the music on this album sounds like? Hands up if you said 'Chilled, Balearic dance, perfect for summer evenings'. Now hands down if you are Andrew Weatherall, aka The Sabres of Paradise. Thought so.